Commit Graph

7 Commits (14638a612f0197e90a163436145a87ccf33d5b2f)

Author SHA1 Message Date
Mike Gerwitz 0cc0bc9d5a tamer: xir::Token::AttrEnd: Remove
More information can be found in the prior commit message, but I'll
summarize here.

This token was introduced to create a LL(0) parser---no tokens of
lookahead.  This allowed the underlying TokenStream to be freely passed to
the next system that needed it.

Since then, Parser and ParseState were introduced, along with
ParseStatus::Dead, which introduces the concept of lookahead for a single
token---an LL(1) grammar.

I had always suspected that this would happen, given the awkwardness of
AttrEnd; it was just a matter of time before the right abstraction
manifested itself to handle lookahead.

DEV-11339
2021-12-17 10:14:31 -05:00
Mike Gerwitz 325c3167ee tamer: xir::Token::span: New method
This permits retrieving a Span from any Token variant.  To support this,
rather than having this return an Option, Token::AttrEnd was augmented with
a Span; this results in a much simpler and friendlier API.

DEV-11268
2021-12-06 14:48:55 -05:00
Mike Gerwitz 5233822322 tamer: xir: Remove Text enum
Like previous commits, this replaces the explicit escaping context with the
convention that all values retrieved from `xir` are unescaped on read and
escaped on write.

Comments are a notable TODO, since we must escape only `--`.

CData is also an issue.  I had _expected_ to use it as a means to avoid
unescaping fragments, but I had forgotten that quick_xml hard-codes escaping
on read, so that it can re-use BytesStart!  That is terribly unfortunate,
and may result in us having to re-implement our own read method in the
future to avoid this nonsense.  So I'm just leaving it as a TODO for now.

DEV-11081
2021-11-15 23:47:14 -05:00
Mike Gerwitz d710437ee4 tamer: xir::escape::CachingEscaper: New Escaper
As promised, this will cache previously seen escaped/unescaped values by
creating a two-way mapping between them.

DEV-11081
2021-11-15 16:44:24 -05:00
Mike Gerwitz 27ba03b59b tamer: xir::escape: Remove XirString in favor of Escaper
This rewrites a good portion of the previous commit.

Rather than explicitly storing whether a given string has been escaped, we
can instead assume that all SymbolIds leaving or entering XIR are unescaped,
because there is no reason for any other part of the system to deal with
such details of XML documents.

Given that, we need only unescape on read and escape on write.  This is
customary, so why didn't I do that to begin with?

The previous commit outlines the reason, mainly being an optimization for
the echo writer that is upcoming.  However, this solution will end up being
better---it's not implemented yet, but we can have a caching layer, such
that the Escaper records a mapping between escaped and unescaped SymbolIds
to avoid work the next time around.  If we share the Escaper between _all_
readers and the writer, the result is that

  1. Duplicate strings between source files and object files (many of which
     are read by both the linker and compiler) avoid re-unescaping; and
  2. Writers can use this cache to avoid re-escaping when we've already seen
     the escaped variant of the string during read.

The alternative would be a global cache, like the internment system, but I
did not find that to be appropriate here, since this is far less
fundamental and is much easier to compose.

DEV-11081
2021-11-12 14:03:23 -05:00
Mike Gerwitz b1c0783c75 tamer: xir::XirString: WIP implementation (likely going away)
I'm not fond of this implementation, which is why it's not fully
completed.  I wanted to commit this for future reference, and take the
opportunity to explain why I don't like it.

First: this task started as an idea to implement a third variant to
AttrValue and friends that indicates that a value is fixed, in the sense of
a fixed-point function: escaped or unescaped, its value is the same.  This
would allow us to skip wasteful escape/unescape operations.

In doing so, it became obvious that there's no need to leak this information
through the API, and indeed, no part of the system should care.  When we
read XML, it should be unescaped, and when we write, it should be
escaped.  The reason that this didn't quite happen to begin with was an
optimization: I'll be creating an echo writer in place of the current
filesystem-based copy in tamec shortly, and this would allow streaming XIR
directly from the reader to the writer without any unescaping or
re-escaping.

When we unescape, we know the value that it came from, so we could simply
store both symbols---they're 32-bit, so it results in a nicely compressed
64-bit value, so it's essentially cost-free, as long as we accept the
expense of internment.  This is `XirString`.  Then, when we want to escape
or unescape, we first check to see whether a symbol already exists and, if
so, use it.

While this works well for echoing streams, it won't work all that well in
practice: the unescaped SymbolId will be taken and the XirString discarded,
since nothing after XIR should be coupled with it.  Then, when we later
construct a XIR stream for writting, XirString will no longer be available
and our previously known escape is lost, so the writer will have to
re-escape.

Further, if we look at XirString's generic for the XirStringEscaper---it
uses phantom, which hints that maybe it's not in the best place.  Indeed,
I've already acknowledged that only a reader unescapes and only a writer
escapes, and that the rest of the system works with normal (unescaped)
values, so only readers and writers should be part of this process.  I also
already acknowledged that XirString would be lost and only the unescaped
SymbolId would be used.

So what's the point of XirString, then, if it won't be a useful optimization
beyond the temporary echo writer?

Instead, we can take the XirStringWriter and implement two caches on that:
mapping SymbolId from escaped->unescaped and vice-versa.  These can be
simple vectors, since SymbolId is a 32-bit value we will not have much
wasted space for symbols that never get read or written.  We could even
optimize for preinterned symbols using markers, though I'll probably not do
so, and I'll explain why later.

If we do _that_, we get even _better_ optimizations through caching that
_will_ apply in the general case (so, not just for echo), and we're able to
ditch XirString entirely and simply use a SymbolId.  This makes for a much
more friendly API that isn't leaking implementation details, though it
_does_ put an onus on the caller to pass the encoder to both the reader and
the writer, _if_ it wants to take advantage of a cache.  But that burden is
not significant (and is, again, optional if we don't want it).

So, that'll be the next step.
2021-11-10 12:22:10 -05:00
Mike Gerwitz 428d508be4 tamer: {ir::=>}{asg, xir}
See the previous commit.  There is no sense in some common "IR" namespace,
since those IRs should live close to whatever system whose data they
represent.

In the case of these, they are general IRs that can apply to many different
parts of the system.  If that proves to be a false statement, they'll be
moved.

DEV-10863
2021-11-04 16:13:27 -04:00